00:00
00:00
Towny

40 Audio Reviews w/ Response

All 72 Reviews

0 reviews are hidden due to your filters.

Damn, I made a rule that if I start taping my foot, I have to leave a review. 1:16 got me hard. I think it's the highlight of the song. You should add more to this project though, it feels a bit bare-boned. Didn't really feel like a "full song" until around 1:16 when that synth kicked in. Making it longer would be cool too, maybe add some vocals? It's up to you man, but this has a lot of potential to be more than just a beat IMO

SuddenGASP responds:

This is some really helpful feedback man, thank you for sharing this. You're absolutely right about it being pretty bare-bones in terms of arrangement - I think I run out of steam too fast when exploring ideas like this. Something to keep in mind for the future at least! And thanks again~

The focus on bass sets the tone very well for an underground subway. Very urban and dark. The segmenting is odd, but I think that kind of sporadic placement lends itself well to a chaotic atmosphere. I do think it could go on a bit longer, though. All in all, interesting mix, good job.

gordody responds:

Thanks for the feedback, v3 is coming!

Using only one instrument can be pretty limiting, but I feel like you really got the best out of it. Love how it picks up at around 1 minute in with the waltz.
One note on the arrangement, your build-ups are great, but moments where you bring the volume down (like 3:08) don't sound natural. You've got the timing correct on how fast it drops at 2:23, but even then it's audibly clear that the volume is just lowered. I think that lowering each string's volume individually, so they don't all lower at once, might make it sound more natural. You could also try introducing a higher note that can eclipse the sound of the strings as they lower, so the enveloping is less noticeable. Or try some EQ tricks, but I try to stay away from those.
Other than that, the composition is great and lively, well composed, and with a little work could make for a professional sounding piece

MajorMusic responds:

Thank you so much for the input I appreciate it a lot.

Glad you decided to go with the vocals, they fit even better than I thought they would, and it really does tie the track together. Also, the volume dynamics are a lot better in this mix. Huge improvement overall, great work!

Psybot responds:

Thank you so much for taking the time to review both versions. :D
I'm glad you like it :)))

I never liked toxic biohazard personally. But you managed to make it sound pretty good, which is impressive. Props to you for that. The piano at the beginning was definitely a good choice to set it apart from the others who use the same synth. I'd love to hear more of that uniqueness in the future, because techno is over-saturated, and I feel like distinguishing yourself is the most important part of being an artist. So DEFINITELY do that intro with lyrics, I think that's a great idea! I look forward to hearing it if you do. Take care

Psybot responds:

As a matter of fact, there is a version in my library with lyrics :) I'm gonna remove this one later because I feel like it became as good as it should be :)

This has a unique sound, it's not bad, but it feels too out of place. I can see the potential of this being, maybe a track put into a larger concept album, but honestly it fails to stand on it's own for me.

ZappaFan52 responds:

You nailed it on the head sir it actually is part of a concept album... sort of haha It's coming out in January

Pretty diverse sound here, and it stays cohesive, I like. Is there a name for that synth sound at 00:16? It has a nice vibe to it

Slickerwolf responds:

it's named dusty record synth, in Garageband.

I liked the choices of reverb, and the stereo spacing is really well done

GameBoyFireworks responds:

Thank you <3

Okay, the vocal sample is really catchy. Other than that, not much stands out, but then again it's not a genre I frequent. I will say though, it sounds very well mixed. Overall a good job, I just think it could be a bit bolder, with more moments like 1:04 where it feels like it really pops. Welcome back btw, I also haven't been on much since '07. The recent influx of traffic to the site has gotten me to return as well. Good luck to ya

Shima33 responds:

Thanks, bud! This sort of feedback is greatly appreciated, and honestly rarely had on other platforms. Newgrounds has always felt a lot more close-knit than other platforms in that sense, and I really respect it for that.

Yeah, this song does get a bit same-y, I'm trying very hard to work myself out of the "same-y" pool, much harder than you'd think actually!

I love the introduction of synths about half way in. It's giving me a strange sense of nostalgia for something, but I can't quite put my finger on it... Anyway, well done

Zechnition responds:

Thanks! I think that's my favorite part too; it's what I centered the song around.

I always enjoy feedback: good/bad/borderline-harassment/I don't care

Matt @Towny

Age 29, Male

Musician

Audacity tutorials from 2007

Newport News, VA

Joined on 2/17/07

Level:
14
Exp Points:
2,084 / 2,180
Exp Rank:
30,148
Vote Power:
5.63 votes
Audio Scouts
2
Rank:
Police Officer
Global Rank:
12,003
Blams:
299
Saves:
490
B/P Bonus:
10%
Whistle:
Normal
Medals:
208
Supporter:
1y 2m 1d